A semiconductor wafer whose number of LPDs per wafer is equal to or smaller than a predetermined number is sorted out, and a judgment as to whether a semiconductor wafer is a non-defective wafer is made visually based on a haze map of the semiconductor wafer subjected to the sorting. Moreover, a semiconductor wafer whose number of LPDs per wafer is equal to or smaller than a predetermined number is sorted out. Then, from the semiconductor wafers subjected to the sorting, a semiconductor wafer whose in-plane standard deviation and in-plane average value of the haze signals in a wafer plane have a specific relationship is sorted out, and this semiconductor wafer is judged to be a non-defective wafer. In this way, a method for judging whether a semiconductor wafer is a non-defective wafer or a defective wafer, the method that can make a judgment more uniform and accurate without dependence on the difference in the S/N ratio between inspection apparatuses using a laser scattering method, is provided.