A data storage system includes a plurality of storage devices organized as a redundant array of inexpensive disks (RAID) storage array and a RAID controller. The RAID controller monitors the plurality of storage devices in the RAID storage array. The RAID controller also detects that a host read request of a host has a latency exceeding a latency threshold. Based on the monitoring, the RAID controller determines whether a proactive rebuild of a data requested by the host read request in absence of a data error would likely be beneficial to performance. Based on determining that a proactive rebuild of the data requested by the host read request would likely be beneficial to performance, the RAID controller initiates the proactive rebuild of the data and sends the requested data to the host.