A method for evaluating security of third-party application is disclosed. The method includes: receiving, from a first application, a request to obtain first account data for a user account associated with a protected data resource; generating fake data for at least a portion of the requested first account data; providing, to the first application, a first data set in response to the request, the first data set including at least the generated fake data; monitoring use of the first data set by the first application; detecting a trigger condition indicating misuse of account data based on monitoring use of the first data set by the first application; in response to detecting the trigger condition, generating a notification identifying the misuse of account data; and transmitting the notification to a computing device associated with an application user.