A perpendicular magnetic recording writer is disclosed wherein a first trailing shield (HMTS) layer has a down-track (DT) thickness d in portions thereof proximate to a center plane that bisects the main pole tip trailing side to enable enhanced trailing shield return field at track center thereby improving bits per inch (BPI) capability. Meanwhile, at off track center positions, that in some embodiments are from 25 nm to 500 nm from the center plane, the HMTS layer has a DT thickness d1, where d1>d, and a smaller dielectric gap between the HMTS layer and the main pole thereby protecting side shield return field and adjacent track interference (ATI) performance. A method of forming the HMTS layer on a write gap is provided and includes patterning the HMTS layer in a back portion to form openings that are filled with the smaller dielectric gap and HTMS layer thickness d1.