During gaming machine play, a plurality of prize identifiers are displayed on a video display Each of the prize identifiers is associated with a prize. A plurality of prize level indicators are displayed with each prize level indicator associated with a respective one of the prize identifiers. During gaming machine play, reward points are accumulated. The plurality of reward points are utilized to determine a proportion of a redemption threshold of points needed for a player to select each prize. The proportion is displayed to the player on the video display.